Case Study 2

| 4 Comments | 0 TrackBacks

Theo is in a large lecture history class. The professor for the class gives a weekly 10 point multiple choice quiz. The professor always reviews the correct answers after returning the graded exams and tells students to let him know if there were grading errors. Theo had caught a grading error three weeks ago where a problem was mistakenly marked incorrect. He showed the professor and immediately got his grade adjusted from 8 points to 9 points. When the exams are returned this week, Theo is delighted with a perfect score of 10, but his pleasure is short-lived for as the instructor reviews the exams, Theo notices another error, but this time the error is in his favor. He actually got a question wrong but the instructor didn't mark it down.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: https://blogs.psu.edu/mt4/mt-tb.cgi/267642

4 Comments

It's a matter of honesty. Sure it would have been great to have a perfect grade on the exam, but if you missed the question, then it isn't really a perfect grade and it wouldn't be fair to yourself or to the rest of the class to have it counted as such.

And there are plenty of professors out there who would give you at least partial credit for your honesty and integrity.

Or, even better, a good letter of recommendation.

You don't deserve the points because you didn't get the question right. It's a question of fairness and honesty.

Why bother. If the professor didn't notice, it's not your job to do his job.

Recent Entries

The Crying Game: Questions for Reflection
This week's selection for Ethical Dilemmas on Film is the 1992 Neil Jordan film The Crying Game. Here are…
Sunset Blvd.: Questions for Reflection
This week's installment in the "Ethical Dilemmas on Film" Series at the State Theatre is the 1950 film noir…
Ethical Leadership in Everyday Encounters
2012 Rock Ethics Institute Stand Up Award Recipient Joshua Brady Branch Class of 2013, Political Science, Schreyer Honors Scholar, Paterno…

Subscribe

  • Subscribe to feed Entries
  • Subscribe to comments feed Comments
  • 520312aaa37552c47fa9f6f2bead013cedcb847ce757330d9dec917c28a26458-2395942084.png
    iTunes U

Join Us On